Bill Miller's Legg Mason Value Trust Fund Shows Why Active Investing Doesn't Work

Article Submitted by: Sam Cass
Stocks - Options - Mutual Funds


Active investing, otherwise known as stock picking is a trillion dollar industry that just doesn't work. Don't believe me? Look at what happened to Bill Miller, until last year considered one of the best stock pickers.

 

Submitted: Dec 10, 2008    Views: 3133    Comments: 1    Likes: 3   


Active investing, otherwise known as stock picking is a trillion dollar industry that just doesn't work.  Millions entrust their money to "financial gurus" who use their superior insight and analysis to find the best stocks and generate the best returns.  In the process, they also charge you a fee. 

It's long been known that active investing does not work.  Sure, an investor may get lucky for a stretch and outperform the market but in the end, everyone reverts back to the mean. Don't believe me?  Look at what happened to Bill Miller, until last year considered one of the best stock pickers.

Below is a chart that shows the performance of Miller's Legg Mason Value Trust fund versus the S&P 500.  The fund outperformed the broader market every year from 1991 to 2005, a run that no other manager can match.  The last couple of years have not been so kind.  

LeggMasonValueTrustVersusS&P500

 

Losses over the last year have wiped out the last ten years of gains.  The WSJ reports that:

"A year ago, his Value Trust fund had $16.5 billion under management. Now, after losses and redemptions, it has assets of $4.3 billion, according to Morningstar Inc. Value Trust's investors have lost 58% of their money over the past year, 20 percentage points worse than the decline on the Standard & Poor's 500 stock index.

These losses have wiped away Value Trust's years of market-beating performance. The fund is now among the worst-performing in its class for the last one-, three-, five- and 10-year periods, according to Morningstar."

Investing money in an actively managed fund is a bad idea for two reasons:

1. The funds over the long run do not outperform broad indexed like the S&P 500.

2. You are paying extra for an "expert" to choose stocks to buy.  This fee reduces also works to reduce your return.

So, what's a better way to invest when you are ready to put money into the market?  Index funds which can be traded as mutual funds or ETFs.  Vanguard has become the largest mutual fund company in the world because of its low fee, index oriented approach.  Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) can be bought and sold that mimic the performance of major indexes.  They also have very low expenses.  The most popular ETFs are SPY (mimics the S&P 500) and QQQQ (mimics the top 100 Nasdaq stocks).  There are now ETFs that track bond markets, commodities, and more.  The key is to choose a fund that has a low expense ratio and tracks a broad market.  

 


Updates and Offers

Subscribe to BestCashCow Weekly Bank Rate Updates and News.




Bank Deal:
Earn 2.25% 3-Month Bonus Rate on Everbank Yield Pledge Money Market Account


Related Articles:



3

Email this story Email to someone | Print Story Print Content | Add to reading list

Comments Received:

That chart sucks
(Unregistered)

This is way late, but yahoo charts are horribly misleading for mutual fund comparisons. They track share price and NOT overall return.

Posted: Oct 8, 2009



Add Your Comments:

Your Name:

Spam protection control:


© Copyright 2010 Sam Cass All rights reserved. Sam Cass has granted BestCashCow.com, LLC non-exclusive rights to display this work on Bestcashcow.com.

Financial products of all nature bear inherent risks and this website is not a financial advisory service; it is a forum for users to share and to compare notes and observations on financial publications. The website provides, free of charge, the technical and logistical apparatus and the medium for users to share and to publish financial information and to comment on publications. As such, the website's operator can not and does not take responsibility for information, observations or opinions of any sort or nature provided by third parties with whom it is not affiliated who use the website to publish, to comment or as a means of solicitation. Users are specifically warned against following any advice related to specific instruments, including, but not limited to, equity securities, that may be provided by other users directly on this site or on web pages to which other users have provided links on this site. BestCashCow.com can not and does not check or verify the qualifications and credentials of users who publish or comment on this site or on linked pages. Users should seek personalized advice from qualified professionals regarding all personal financial issues and evaluate the risks and applicability to their own circumstances of each financial product discussed regardless of who the publisher is or purports to be. Should you, through your use of this site, identify an individual or organization purporting to offer personalized advice, you bear all responsibility to ensure that the individual or organization has the qualifications that they may represent on the website, and that their advice is appropriate for your circumstances. On certain webpages, BestCashCow.com provides information related to rates on US-based savings accounts, CDs, short-term government bonds, and other US cash equivalent securities, also free of charge to internet users for their independent use. The accuracy of this information is not guaranteed, and the information, like all other information on this website, should not be construed to provide investment advice, nor to endorse a financial product of any sort.

© 2010 BestCashCow.com, LLC. All Rights Reserved. Terms under which this service is provided to you. Privacy Policy.