• Home
  • Compare Products

Compare Savings vs. CDs
Comparison of Deposit Account from MEMBERS 1ST with 1.50% - December 2025


Long-Term Analysis of NBH Bank with 0.50% APY and MUTUAL SAVINGS with 2.75% APY and The Watkins Savings Bank with 0.70% APY and EFCU FINANCIAL with 0.85% APY and Old National Bank with 0.30% APY and GREATER METRO with 0.20% APY and QUALSTAR with 0.55% APY and CHESSIE with 0.70% APY and The Converse County Bank with 1.60% APY and MEMBERS 1ST with 1.50% APY and Renasant Bank with 4.00% APY

This analysis is for demonstrative purposes only. Savings rates may go up or down, and CD rates may not be renewable for the length of the term of the analysis.

You May Choose More Savings or CD Products From Among these Popular Products to Compare

 
$
PRODUCT
BANK
APY
STATE
AMOUNT
TERM
BANK TYPE
VS.NAT.AV.
MIN
  • 1
    LOCAL CD
    NBH Bank
    0.50%
    -
    $50,000
    24 Month
    Bank
    0.76x (National Avg. - 0.66%)
    $10,000
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    0.50%    		 Annual
    Interest    		 Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 250 175
    2 50,250 251 176
    3 50,501 253 177
    4 50,754 254 178
    5 51,008 255 179
    6 51,263 256 179
    7 51,519 258 180
    8 51,776 259 181
    9 52,035 260 182
    10 52,296 261 183
    11 52,557 263 184
    12 52,820 264 185
    13 53,084 265 186
    14 53,349 267 187
    15 53,616 268 188
    16 53,884 269 189
    17 54,154 271 190
    18 54,424 272 190
    19 54,696 273 191
    20 54,970 275 192
    TOTAL $5,245 $3,671
  • 2
    LOCAL CD
    MUTUAL SAVINGS
    2.75%
    -
    $50,000
    6 Month
    Credit Union
    6.79x (National Avg. - 0.41%)
    $100
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    2.75%    		 Annual
    Interest    		 Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 1,375 963
    2 51,375 1,413 989
    3 52,788 1,452 1,016
    4 54,239 1,492 1,044
    5 55,731 1,533 1,073
    6 57,264 1,575 1,102
    7 58,838 1,618 1,133
    8 60,456 1,663 1,164
    9 62,119 1,708 1,196
    10 63,827 1,755 1,229
    11 65,583 1,804 1,262
    12 67,386 1,853 1,297
    13 69,239 1,904 1,333
    14 71,143 1,956 1,370
    15 73,100 2,010 1,407
    16 75,110 2,066 1,446
    17 77,175 2,122 1,486
    18 79,298 2,181 1,526
    19 81,478 2,241 1,568
    20 83,719 2,302 1,612
    TOTAL $36,021 $25,215
  • 3
    LOCAL CD
    The Watkins Savings Bank
    0.70%
    -
    $50,000
    18 Month
    Bank
    1.21x (National Avg. - 0.58%)
    $100,000
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    0.70%    		 Annual
    Interest    		 Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 350 245
    2 50,350 352 247
    3 50,702 355 248
    4 51,057 357 250
    5 51,415 360 252
    6 51,775 362 254
    7 52,137 365 255
    8 52,502 368 257
    9 52,870 370 259
    10 53,240 373 261
    11 53,612 375 263
    12 53,988 378 265
    13 54,366 381 266
    14 54,746 383 268
    15 55,129 386 270
    16 55,515 389 272
    17 55,904 391 274
    18 56,295 394 276
    19 56,689 397 278
    20 57,086 400 280
    TOTAL $7,486 $5,240
  • 4
    LOCAL CD
    EFCU FINANCIAL
    0.85%
    -
    $50,000
    6 Month
    Credit Union
    2.10x (National Avg. - 0.41%)
    $100,000
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    0.85%    		 Annual
    Interest    		 Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 425 298
    2 50,425 429 300
    3 50,854 432 303
    4 51,286 436 305
    5 51,722 440 308
    6 52,161 443 310
    7 52,605 447 313
    8 53,052 451 316
    9 53,503 455 318
    10 53,958 459 321
    11 54,416 463 324
    12 54,879 466 327
    13 55,345 470 329
    14 55,816 474 332
    15 56,290 478 335
    16 56,769 483 338
    17 57,251 487 341
    18 57,738 491 344
    19 58,229 495 346
    20 58,724 499 349
    TOTAL $9,223 $6,456
  • 5
    LOCAL CD
    Old National Bank
    0.30%
    -
    $50,000
    36 Month
    Bank
    0.40x (National Avg. - 0.75%)
    $10,000
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    0.30%    		 Annual
    Interest    		 Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 150 105
    2 50,150 150 105
    3 50,300 151 106
    4 50,451 151 106
    5 50,603 152 106
    6 50,755 152 107
    7 50,907 153 107
    8 51,059 153 107
    9 51,213 154 108
    10 51,366 154 108
    11 51,520 155 108
    12 51,675 155 109
    13 51,830 155 109
    14 51,985 156 109
    15 52,141 156 109
    16 52,298 157 110
    17 52,455 157 110
    18 52,612 158 110
    19 52,770 158 111
    20 52,928 159 111
    TOTAL $3,087 $2,161
  • 6
    LOCAL MONEY MARKET
    GREATER METRO
    0.20%
    -
    $50,000
    N.A.
    Credit Union
    0.27x (National Avg. - 0.75%)
    $25,000
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    0.20%    		 Annual
    Interest    		 Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 100 70
    2 50,100 100 70
    3 50,200 100 70
    4 50,301 101 70
    5 50,401 101 71
    6 50,502 101 71
    7 50,603 101 71
    8 50,704 101 71
    9 50,806 102 71
    10 50,907 102 71
    11 51,009 102 71
    12 51,111 102 72
    13 51,213 102 72
    14 51,316 103 72
    15 51,418 103 72
    16 51,521 103 72
    17 51,624 103 72
    18 51,727 103 72
    19 51,831 104 73
    20 51,935 104 73
    TOTAL $2,038 $1,427
  • 7
    LOCAL CD
    QUALSTAR
    0.55%
    -
    $50,000
    18 Month
    Credit Union
    0.95x (National Avg. - 0.58%)
    $100,000
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    0.55%    		 Annual
    Interest    		 Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 275 193
    2 50,275 277 194
    3 50,552 278 195
    4 50,830 280 196
    5 51,109 281 197
    6 51,390 283 198
    7 51,673 284 199
    8 51,957 286 200
    9 52,243 287 201
    10 52,530 289 202
    11 52,819 291 203
    12 53,110 292 204
    13 53,402 294 206
    14 53,695 295 207
    15 53,991 297 208
    16 54,288 299 209
    17 54,586 300 210
    18 54,886 302 211
    19 55,188 304 212
    20 55,492 305 214
    TOTAL $5,797 $4,058
  • 8
    LOCAL CD
    CHESSIE
    0.70%
    -
    $50,000
    24 Month
    Credit Union
    1.06x (National Avg. - 0.66%)
    $10,000
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    0.70%    		 Annual
    Interest    		 Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 350 245
    2 50,350 352 247
    3 50,702 355 248
    4 51,057 357 250
    5 51,415 360 252
    6 51,775 362 254
    7 52,137 365 255
    8 52,502 368 257
    9 52,870 370 259
    10 53,240 373 261
    11 53,612 375 263
    12 53,988 378 265
    13 54,366 381 266
    14 54,746 383 268
    15 55,129 386 270
    16 55,515 389 272
    17 55,904 391 274
    18 56,295 394 276
    19 56,689 397 278
    20 57,086 400 280
    TOTAL $7,486 $5,240
  • 9
    LOCAL CD
    The Converse County Bank
    1.60%
    -
    $50,000
    36 Month
    Bank
    2.12x (National Avg. - 0.75%)
    $10,000
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    1.60%    		 Annual
    Interest    		 Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 800 560
    2 50,800 813 569
    3 51,613 826 578
    4 52,439 839 587
    5 53,278 852 597
    6 54,130 866 606
    7 54,996 880 616
    8 55,876 894 626
    9 56,770 908 636
    10 57,678 923 646
    11 58,601 938 656
    12 59,539 953 667
    13 60,492 968 678
    14 61,459 983 688
    15 62,443 999 699
    16 63,442 1,015 711
    17 64,457 1,031 722
    18 65,488 1,048 733
    19 66,536 1,065 745
    20 67,601 1,082 757
    TOTAL $18,682 $13,078
  • 10
    LOCAL CD
    MEMBERS 1ST
    1.50%
    -
    $50,000
    24 Month
    Credit Union
    2.27x (National Avg. - 0.66%)
    $1,000,000
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    1.50%    		 Annual
    Interest    		 Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 750 525
    2 50,750 761 533
    3 51,511 773 541
    4 52,284 784 549
    5 53,068 796 557
    6 53,864 808 566
    7 54,672 820 574
    8 55,492 832 583
    9 56,325 845 591
    10 57,169 858 600
    11 58,027 870 609
    12 58,897 883 618
    13 59,781 897 628
    14 60,678 910 637
    15 61,588 924 647
    16 62,512 938 656
    17 63,449 952 666
    18 64,401 966 676
    19 65,367 981 686
    20 66,348 995 697
    TOTAL $17,343 $12,140
  • 11
    LOCAL CD
    Renasant Bank
    4.00%
    -
    $50,000
    7 Month
    Bank
    N.A.
    $1,000
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    4.00%    		 Annual
    Interest    		 Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 2,000 1,400
    2 52,000 2,080 1,456
    3 54,080 2,163 1,514
    4 56,243 2,250 1,575
    5 58,493 2,340 1,638
    6 60,833 2,433 1,703
    7 63,266 2,531 1,771
    8 65,797 2,632 1,842
    9 68,428 2,737 1,916
    10 71,166 2,847 1,993
    11 74,012 2,960 2,072
    12 76,973 3,079 2,155
    13 80,052 3,202 2,241
    14 83,254 3,330 2,331
    15 86,584 3,463 2,424
    16 90,047 3,602 2,521
    17 93,649 3,746 2,622
    18 97,395 3,896 2,727
    19 101,291 4,052 2,836
    20 105,342 4,214 2,950
    TOTAL $59,556 $41,689

    All calculations are for demonstration purposes only.

    Featured CD Rates

    ONLINE BANKS APY? MIN?

    Last change: ↓0.16% on September 18.
    3 Month CD.

    Last change: ↑0.20% on December 7.
    Early Withdrawal Penalty is 6 months interest.

    Last change: ↑0.05% on December 1.

    Last change: ↑0.10% on December 1.
    Early Withdrawal Penalty is 90 days interest.

    Last change: ↓0.15% on November 26.

    Reddit

    Featured on:

    Copyright © 2025 BestCashCow.com, LLC. All Rights Reserved. Our Terms and Conditions. Privacy Policy + CCPA.

    Disclosure Governing Your Use of this Website | Advertising Disclosure

    Last Update on December 14, 2025

    This page was created in 5.2541 seconds.