Compare Savings vs. CDs
Comparison of Deposit Account from MEMBERS 1ST with 1.20% - May 2024


Long-Term Analysis of Fortress Bank with 0.35% APY and Gateway Bank with 1.27% APY and ORION with 0.64% APY and InBank with 0.30% APY and Four Corners Community Bank with 0.75% APY and FIRST FINANCIAL with 0.75% APY and NORTHPARK COMMUNITY with 0.25% APY and CENTRAL CREDIT UNION OF MARYLAND,IN with 0.40% APY and HARBORLIGHT with 0.45% APY and Garfield County Bank with 0.95% APY and Town & Country Bank with 0.95% APY and The Union Bank Company with 2.27% APY and The Ottoville Bank Company with 0.20% APY and UKRAINIAN with 1.21% APY and The Home Savings and Loan Company of Kenton, Ohio with 0.20% APY and WAYNE COUNTY COMMUNITY with 0.30% APY and The Fidelity Deposit and Discount Bank with 0.40% APY and Cornerstone Bank with 0.50% APY and FANNIN with 1.31% APY and ENTERPRISE with 0.70% APY and POLICE & FIRE with 4.00% APY and Finworth, a division of InsBank with 4.80% APY and MEMBERS 1ST with 1.20% APY and MEMBERS 1ST with 1.40% APY and THREE RIVERS with 2.25% APY

This analysis is for demonstrative purposes only. Savings rates may go up or down, and CD rates may not be renewable for the length of the term of the analysis.

You May Choose More Savings or CD Products From Among these Popular Products to Compare

 
$
PRODUCT
BANK
APY
STATE
AMOUNT
TERM
BANK TYPE
VS.NAT.AV.
MIN
  • 1
    LOCAL CD
    0.35%
    -
    $50,000
    6 Month
    Bank
    0.51x (National Avg. - 0.69%)
    $50,000
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    0.35%
    Annual
    Interest
    Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 175 123
    2 50,175 176 123
    3 50,351 176 123
    4 50,527 177 124
    5 50,704 177 124
    6 50,881 178 125
    7 51,059 179 125
    8 51,238 179 126
    9 51,417 180 126
    10 51,597 181 126
    11 51,778 181 127
    12 51,959 182 127
    13 52,141 182 128
    14 52,323 183 128
    15 52,507 184 129
    16 52,690 184 129
    17 52,875 185 130
    18 53,060 186 130
    19 53,245 186 130
    20 53,432 187 131
    TOTAL $3,619 $2,533
  • 2
    LOCAL CD
    1.27%
    -
    $50,000
    36 Month
    Bank
    1.46x (National Avg. - 0.87%)
    $10,000
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    1.27%
    Annual
    Interest
    Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 635 445
    2 50,635 643 450
    3 51,278 651 456
    4 51,929 660 462
    5 52,589 668 468
    6 53,257 676 473
    7 53,933 685 479
    8 54,618 694 486
    9 55,312 702 492
    10 56,014 711 498
    11 56,725 720 504
    12 57,446 730 511
    13 58,175 739 517
    14 58,914 748 524
    15 59,662 758 530
    16 60,420 767 537
    17 61,188 777 544
    18 61,965 787 551
    19 62,752 797 558
    20 63,549 807 565
    TOTAL $14,356 $10,049
  • 3
    LOCAL CD
    0.64%
    -
    $50,000
    36 Month
    Credit Union
    0.73x (National Avg. - 0.87%)
    $100,000
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    0.64%
    Annual
    Interest
    Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 320 224
    2 50,320 322 225
    3 50,642 324 227
    4 50,966 326 228
    5 51,292 328 230
    6 51,621 330 231
    7 51,951 332 233
    8 52,283 335 234
    9 52,618 337 236
    10 52,955 339 237
    11 53,294 341 239
    12 53,635 343 240
    13 53,978 345 242
    14 54,324 348 243
    15 54,671 350 245
    16 55,021 352 246
    17 55,373 354 248
    18 55,728 357 250
    19 56,084 359 251
    20 56,443 361 253
    TOTAL $6,804 $4,763
  • 4
    LOCAL CD
    0.30%
    -
    $50,000
    36 Month
    Bank
    0.34x (National Avg. - 0.87%)
    $10,000
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    0.30%
    Annual
    Interest
    Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 150 105
    2 50,150 150 105
    3 50,300 151 106
    4 50,451 151 106
    5 50,603 152 106
    6 50,755 152 107
    7 50,907 153 107
    8 51,059 153 107
    9 51,213 154 108
    10 51,366 154 108
    11 51,520 155 108
    12 51,675 155 109
    13 51,830 155 109
    14 51,985 156 109
    15 52,141 156 109
    16 52,298 157 110
    17 52,455 157 110
    18 52,612 158 110
    19 52,770 158 111
    20 52,928 159 111
    TOTAL $3,087 $2,161
  • 5
    LOCAL CD
    0.75%
    -
    $50,000
    18 Month
    Bank
    1.03x (National Avg. - 0.73%)
    $10,000
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    0.75%
    Annual
    Interest
    Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 375 263
    2 50,375 378 264
    3 50,753 381 266
    4 51,133 384 268
    5 51,517 386 270
    6 51,903 389 272
    7 52,293 392 275
    8 52,685 395 277
    9 53,080 398 279
    10 53,478 401 281
    11 53,879 404 283
    12 54,283 407 285
    13 54,690 410 287
    14 55,101 413 289
    15 55,514 416 291
    16 55,930 419 294
    17 56,350 423 296
    18 56,772 426 298
    19 57,198 429 300
    20 57,627 432 303
    TOTAL $8,059 $5,641
  • 6
    LOCAL CD
    0.75%
    -
    $50,000
    18 Month
    Credit Union
    1.03x (National Avg. - 0.73%)
    $100,000
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    0.75%
    Annual
    Interest
    Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 375 263
    2 50,375 378 264
    3 50,753 381 266
    4 51,133 384 268
    5 51,517 386 270
    6 51,903 389 272
    7 52,293 392 275
    8 52,685 395 277
    9 53,080 398 279
    10 53,478 401 281
    11 53,879 404 283
    12 54,283 407 285
    13 54,690 410 287
    14 55,101 413 289
    15 55,514 416 291
    16 55,930 419 294
    17 56,350 423 296
    18 56,772 426 298
    19 57,198 429 300
    20 57,627 432 303
    TOTAL $8,059 $5,641
  • 7
    LOCAL CD
    0.25%
    -
    $50,000
    30 Month
    Credit Union
    N.A.
    $100,000
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    0.25%
    Annual
    Interest
    Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 125 88
    2 50,125 125 88
    3 50,250 126 88
    4 50,376 126 88
    5 50,502 126 88
    6 50,628 127 89
    7 50,755 127 89
    8 50,882 127 89
    9 51,009 128 89
    10 51,136 128 89
    11 51,264 128 90
    12 51,392 128 90
    13 51,521 129 90
    14 51,650 129 90
    15 51,779 129 91
    16 51,908 130 91
    17 52,038 130 91
    18 52,168 130 91
    19 52,298 131 92
    20 52,429 131 92
    TOTAL $2,560 $1,792
  • 8
    LOCAL CD
    0.40%
    -
    $50,000
    12 Month
    Credit Union
    0.48x (National Avg. - 0.84%)
    $100,000
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    0.40%
    Annual
    Interest
    Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 201 140
    2 50,201 201 141
    3 50,402 202 141
    4 50,604 203 142
    5 50,807 204 143
    6 51,011 205 143
    7 51,215 205 144
    8 51,420 206 144
    9 51,627 207 145
    10 51,834 208 145
    11 52,042 209 146
    12 52,250 210 147
    13 52,460 210 147
    14 52,670 211 148
    15 52,881 212 148
    16 53,093 213 149
    17 53,306 214 150
    18 53,520 215 150
    19 53,735 215 151
    20 53,950 216 151
    TOTAL $4,166 $2,917
  • 9
    LOCAL CD
    0.45%
    -
    $50,000
    6 Month
    Credit Union
    0.66x (National Avg. - 0.69%)
    $100,000
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    0.45%
    Annual
    Interest
    Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 225 158
    2 50,225 226 158
    3 50,451 227 159
    4 50,678 228 160
    5 50,906 229 160
    6 51,135 230 161
    7 51,365 231 162
    8 51,596 232 163
    9 51,829 233 163
    10 52,062 234 164
    11 52,296 235 165
    12 52,531 236 165
    13 52,768 237 166
    14 53,005 239 167
    15 53,244 240 168
    16 53,483 241 168
    17 53,724 242 169
    18 53,966 243 170
    19 54,209 244 171
    20 54,453 245 172
    TOTAL $4,698 $3,288
  • 10
    LOCAL CD
    0.95%
    -
    $50,000
    36 Month
    Bank
    1.09x (National Avg. - 0.87%)
    $10,000
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    0.95%
    Annual
    Interest
    Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 475 333
    2 50,475 480 336
    3 50,955 484 339
    4 51,439 489 342
    5 51,927 493 345
    6 52,421 498 349
    7 52,919 503 352
    8 53,421 508 355
    9 53,929 512 359
    10 54,441 517 362
    11 54,958 522 365
    12 55,480 527 369
    13 56,007 532 372
    14 56,540 537 376
    15 57,077 542 380
    16 57,619 547 383
    17 58,166 553 387
    18 58,719 558 390
    19 59,277 563 394
    20 59,840 568 398
    TOTAL $10,408 $7,286
  • 11
    LOCAL CD
    0.95%
    -
    $50,000
    36 Month
    Bank
    1.09x (National Avg. - 0.87%)
    $100,000
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    0.95%
    Annual
    Interest
    Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 475 333
    2 50,475 480 336
    3 50,955 484 339
    4 51,439 489 342
    5 51,927 493 345
    6 52,421 498 349
    7 52,919 503 352
    8 53,421 508 355
    9 53,929 512 359
    10 54,441 517 362
    11 54,958 522 365
    12 55,480 527 369
    13 56,007 532 372
    14 56,540 537 376
    15 57,077 542 380
    16 57,619 547 383
    17 58,166 553 387
    18 58,719 558 390
    19 59,277 563 394
    20 59,840 568 398
    TOTAL $10,408 $7,286
  • 12
    LOCAL MONEY MARKET
    2.27%
    -
    $50,000
    N.A.
    Bank
    2.60x (National Avg. - 0.87%)
    $0
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    2.27%
    Annual
    Interest
    Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 1,135 795
    2 51,135 1,161 813
    3 52,296 1,187 831
    4 53,483 1,214 850
    5 54,697 1,242 869
    6 55,939 1,270 889
    7 57,208 1,299 909
    8 58,507 1,328 930
    9 59,835 1,358 951
    10 61,193 1,389 972
    11 62,582 1,421 994
    12 64,003 1,453 1,017
    13 65,456 1,486 1,040
    14 66,942 1,520 1,064
    15 68,461 1,554 1,088
    16 70,015 1,589 1,113
    17 71,605 1,625 1,138
    18 73,230 1,662 1,164
    19 74,893 1,700 1,190
    20 76,593 1,739 1,217
    TOTAL $28,331 $19,832
  • 13
    LOCAL MONEY MARKET
    0.20%
    -
    $50,000
    N.A.
    Bank
    0.23x (National Avg. - 0.87%)
    $25,000
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    0.20%
    Annual
    Interest
    Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 100 70
    2 50,100 100 70
    3 50,200 100 70
    4 50,301 101 70
    5 50,401 101 71
    6 50,502 101 71
    7 50,603 101 71
    8 50,704 101 71
    9 50,806 102 71
    10 50,907 102 71
    11 51,009 102 71
    12 51,111 102 72
    13 51,213 102 72
    14 51,316 103 72
    15 51,418 103 72
    16 51,521 103 72
    17 51,624 103 72
    18 51,727 103 72
    19 51,831 104 73
    20 51,935 104 73
    TOTAL $2,038 $1,427
  • 14
    LOCAL CD
    1.21%
    -
    $50,000
    60 Month
    Credit Union
    1.33x (National Avg. - 0.91%)
    $100,000
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    1.21%
    Annual
    Interest
    Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 605 424
    2 50,605 612 429
    3 51,217 620 434
    4 51,837 627 439
    5 52,464 635 444
    6 53,099 642 450
    7 53,742 650 455
    8 54,392 658 461
    9 55,050 666 466
    10 55,716 674 472
    11 56,390 682 478
    12 57,073 691 483
    13 57,763 699 489
    14 58,462 707 495
    15 59,170 716 501
    16 59,885 725 507
    17 60,610 733 513
    18 61,343 742 520
    19 62,086 751 526
    20 62,837 760 532
    TOTAL $13,597 $9,518
  • 15
    LOCAL MONEY MARKET
    0.20%
    -
    $50,000
    N.A.
    Bank
    0.22x (National Avg. - 0.91%)
    $2,500
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    0.20%
    Annual
    Interest
    Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 100 70
    2 50,100 100 70
    3 50,200 100 70
    4 50,301 101 70
    5 50,401 101 71
    6 50,502 101 71
    7 50,603 101 71
    8 50,704 101 71
    9 50,806 102 71
    10 50,907 102 71
    11 51,009 102 71
    12 51,111 102 72
    13 51,213 102 72
    14 51,316 103 72
    15 51,418 103 72
    16 51,521 103 72
    17 51,624 103 72
    18 51,727 103 72
    19 51,831 104 73
    20 51,935 104 73
    TOTAL $2,038 $1,427
  • 16
    LOCAL CD
    0.30%
    -
    $50,000
    6 Month
    Credit Union
    0.44x (National Avg. - 0.69%)
    $100,000
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    0.30%
    Annual
    Interest
    Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 150 105
    2 50,150 150 105
    3 50,300 151 106
    4 50,451 151 106
    5 50,603 152 106
    6 50,755 152 107
    7 50,907 153 107
    8 51,059 153 107
    9 51,213 154 108
    10 51,366 154 108
    11 51,520 155 108
    12 51,675 155 109
    13 51,830 155 109
    14 51,985 156 109
    15 52,141 156 109
    16 52,298 157 110
    17 52,455 157 110
    18 52,612 158 110
    19 52,770 158 111
    20 52,928 159 111
    TOTAL $3,087 $2,161
  • 17
    LOCAL CD
    0.40%
    -
    $50,000
    30 Month
    Bank
    N.A.
    $100,000
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    0.40%
    Annual
    Interest
    Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 200 140
    2 50,200 201 141
    3 50,401 202 141
    4 50,602 202 142
    5 50,805 203 142
    6 51,008 204 143
    7 51,212 205 143
    8 51,417 206 144
    9 51,623 206 145
    10 51,829 207 145
    11 52,036 208 146
    12 52,245 209 146
    13 52,454 210 147
    14 52,663 211 147
    15 52,874 211 148
    16 53,085 212 149
    17 53,298 213 149
    18 53,511 214 150
    19 53,725 215 150
    20 53,940 216 151
    TOTAL $4,156 $2,909
  • 18
    LOCAL CD
    0.50%
    -
    $50,000
    18 Month
    Bank
    0.69x (National Avg. - 0.73%)
    $10,000
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    0.50%
    Annual
    Interest
    Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 250 175
    2 50,250 251 176
    3 50,501 253 177
    4 50,754 254 178
    5 51,008 255 179
    6 51,263 256 179
    7 51,519 258 180
    8 51,776 259 181
    9 52,035 260 182
    10 52,296 261 183
    11 52,557 263 184
    12 52,820 264 185
    13 53,084 265 186
    14 53,349 267 187
    15 53,616 268 188
    16 53,884 269 189
    17 54,154 271 190
    18 54,424 272 190
    19 54,696 273 191
    20 54,970 275 192
    TOTAL $5,245 $3,671
  • 19
    LOCAL CD
    1.31%
    -
    $50,000
    24 Month
    Credit Union
    1.38x (National Avg. - 0.95%)
    $100,000
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    1.31%
    Annual
    Interest
    Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 654 458
    2 50,654 663 464
    3 51,317 671 470
    4 51,988 680 476
    5 52,668 689 482
    6 53,357 698 489
    7 54,055 707 495
    8 54,762 716 501
    9 55,478 726 508
    10 56,204 735 515
    11 56,939 745 521
    12 57,683 754 528
    13 58,438 764 535
    14 59,202 774 542
    15 59,977 784 549
    16 60,761 795 556
    17 61,556 805 564
    18 62,361 816 571
    19 63,177 826 578
    20 64,003 837 586
    TOTAL $14,840 $10,388
  • 20
    LOCAL CD
    0.70%
    -
    $50,000
    60 Month
    Credit Union
    0.77x (National Avg. - 0.91%)
    $100,000
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    0.70%
    Annual
    Interest
    Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 350 245
    2 50,350 352 247
    3 50,702 355 248
    4 51,057 357 250
    5 51,415 360 252
    6 51,775 362 254
    7 52,137 365 255
    8 52,502 368 257
    9 52,870 370 259
    10 53,240 373 261
    11 53,612 375 263
    12 53,988 378 265
    13 54,366 381 266
    14 54,746 383 268
    15 55,129 386 270
    16 55,515 389 272
    17 55,904 391 274
    18 56,295 394 276
    19 56,689 397 278
    20 57,086 400 280
    TOTAL $7,486 $5,240
  • 21
    LOCAL CD
    4.00%
    -
    $50,000
    15 Month
    Credit Union
    N.A.
    $50,000
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    4.00%
    Annual
    Interest
    Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 2,000 1,400
    2 52,000 2,080 1,456
    3 54,080 2,163 1,514
    4 56,243 2,250 1,575
    5 58,493 2,340 1,638
    6 60,833 2,433 1,703
    7 63,266 2,531 1,771
    8 65,797 2,632 1,842
    9 68,428 2,737 1,916
    10 71,166 2,847 1,993
    11 74,012 2,960 2,072
    12 76,973 3,079 2,155
    13 80,052 3,202 2,241
    14 83,254 3,330 2,331
    15 86,584 3,463 2,424
    16 90,047 3,602 2,521
    17 93,649 3,746 2,622
    18 97,395 3,896 2,727
    19 101,291 4,052 2,836
    20 105,342 4,214 2,950
    TOTAL $59,556 $41,689
  • 22
    ONLINE CD
    4.80%
    -
    $50,000
    22 Month
    Online Bank
    N.A.
    $50,000
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    4.80%
    Annual
    Interest
    Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 2,400 1,680
    2 52,400 2,515 1,761
    3 54,915 2,636 1,845
    4 57,551 2,762 1,934
    5 60,314 2,895 2,027
    6 63,209 3,034 2,124
    7 66,243 3,180 2,226
    8 69,422 3,332 2,333
    9 72,755 3,492 2,445
    10 76,247 3,660 2,562
    11 79,907 3,836 2,685
    12 83,742 4,020 2,814
    13 87,762 4,213 2,949
    14 91,974 4,415 3,090
    15 96,389 4,627 3,239
    16 101,016 4,849 3,394
    17 105,865 5,081 3,557
    18 110,946 5,325 3,728
    19 116,271 5,581 3,907
    20 121,852 5,849 4,094
    TOTAL $77,701 $54,391
  • 23
    LOCAL CD
    1.20%
    -
    $50,000
    30 Month
    Credit Union
    N.A.
    $500
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    1.20%
    Annual
    Interest
    Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 600 420
    2 50,600 607 425
    3 51,207 614 430
    4 51,822 622 435
    5 52,444 629 441
    6 53,073 637 446
    7 53,710 645 451
    8 54,354 652 457
    9 55,007 660 462
    10 55,667 668 468
    11 56,335 676 473
    12 57,011 684 479
    13 57,695 692 485
    14 58,387 701 490
    15 59,088 709 496
    16 59,797 718 502
    17 60,514 726 508
    18 61,240 735 514
    19 61,975 744 521
    20 62,719 753 527
    TOTAL $13,472 $9,430
  • 24
    LOCAL CD
    1.40%
    -
    $50,000
    48 Month
    Credit Union
    1.47x (National Avg. - 0.95%)
    $500
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    1.40%
    Annual
    Interest
    Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 700 490
    2 50,700 710 497
    3 51,410 720 504
    4 52,130 730 511
    5 52,859 740 518
    6 53,599 750 525
    7 54,350 761 533
    8 55,111 772 540
    9 55,882 782 548
    10 56,665 793 555
    11 57,458 804 563
    12 58,262 816 571
    13 59,078 827 579
    14 59,905 839 587
    15 60,744 850 595
    16 61,594 862 604
    17 62,456 874 612
    18 63,331 887 621
    19 64,217 899 629
    20 65,117 912 638
    TOTAL $16,028 $11,220
  • 25
    N.A.
    2.25%
    -
    $50,000
    N.A.
    Credit Union
    2.37x (National Avg. - 0.95%)
    $100,000
     
    SCENARIO
    Year Rate
    2.25%
    Annual
    Interest
    Annual Interest
    (After Tax)
    1 50,000 1,125 788
    2 51,125 1,150 805
    3 52,275 1,176 823
    4 53,452 1,203 842
    5 54,654 1,230 861
    6 55,884 1,257 880
    7 57,141 1,286 900
    8 58,427 1,315 920
    9 59,742 1,344 941
    10 61,086 1,374 962
    11 62,460 1,405 984
    12 63,866 1,437 1,006
    13 65,302 1,469 1,029
    14 66,772 1,502 1,052
    15 68,274 1,536 1,075
    16 69,810 1,571 1,100
    17 71,381 1,606 1,124
    18 72,987 1,642 1,150
    19 74,629 1,679 1,175
    20 76,309 1,717 1,202
    TOTAL $28,025 $19,618

    All calculations are for demonstration purposes only.

    Featured CD Rates

    ONLINE BANKS APY? MIN?

    5 Month CD Special. Must be linked to a standard consumer or business checking account in which 12.6% of the total combined balance is maintained. Otherwise APY is 5.25%.

    Last change: ↓0.15% on May 13.
    3 Month CD.

    Last change: ↑0.09% on March 12.
    6 Month Jumbo CD.

    Last change: ↓0.05% on May 9.

    Last change: ↓0.36% on March 12.
    Early Withdrawal Penalty is 3 months interest.