How Second Mortgages Were Marketed as Home Equities and Captured America's Hearts and Minds
How Second Mortgages Were Marketed as Home Equities and Captured America's Hearts and Minds
Author:Sol Nasisi
on August 16, 2008
- modified on July 15, 2020
Over the last twenty years, financial companies have marketed second mortgages as home equity loans and lines and made it acceptable to borrow against your house. Consumers eagerly gobbled them up.
Have you taken out a home equity line or loan? If so, you've joined millions of others who have borrowed against their home's values. As the NY Times reports, over the last twenty years, home equity lines and loans have exploded in popularity:
"Since the early 1980s, the value of home equity loans outstanding has ballooned to more than $1 trillion from $1 billion, and nearly a quarter of Americans with first mortgages have them. That explosive growth has been a boon for banks. Banks’ returns on fixed-rate home equity loans and lines of credit, which are the most popular, are 25 percent to 50 percent higher than returns on consumer loans over all, with much of that premium coming from relatively high fees."
Unfortunately, with home prices falling and the economy softening, all of this debt is hurting many households.
"The portion of people who have home equity lines more than 30 days past due stands 55 percent above its average since the American Bankers Association began tracking it around 1990; delinquencies on home equity loans are 45 percent higher. Hundreds of thousands are delinquent, owing banks more than $10 billion on these loans, often on top of their first mortgages.
None of this would have been possible without a conscious effort by lenders, who have spent billions of dollars in advertising to change the language of home loans and with it Americans’ attitudes toward debt."
I worked at a large bank in the mid-2000s and remember the marketing machine that was put together to push these products out the door. Banks consciously targeted consumers, changing the name of the product from second mortgage to home equity to make it more palpable to consumers. There were television commercials, sophisticated direct mail programs, credit scoring, and all kinds of programs to sell and cross-sell home equities to as many customers as possible.
That being said, the banks never lied about the product. Consumers knew what they were getting themselves into and really didn't care about the risks. When the bank tried to provide customers with financial guidance and education on debt management, most consumers were only mildly interested . Many of my friends eagerly opened home equity lines and loans, seeing it as found money. So, who's to blame? The banks who pushed the product, or the consumers who eagerly gobbled it up?
The Times article quotes Sendhil Mullainathan, an economist at Harvard who has studied persuasion in financial advertising as saying:
“It’s very difficult for one advertiser to come to you and change your perspective. But as it becomes socially acceptable for everyone to accumulate debt, everyone does.”
I personally think that as the government racked up billion dollar deficits throughout the 80s and 90s, the concept of fiscal prudence and responsibility went out the door. Home owners who were once accustomed to paying down their mortgage now saw it as a source of borrowing power and like the government, tapped that source. Banks were only too eager to jump upon the bandwagon and fan the flames with some advertising lighter fluid.
Sol Nasisi: Sol Nasisi is the co-founder and a past president of BestCashCow, an online resource for comprehensive bank rate information. In this capacity, he closely followed rate trends for all savings-related and loan products and the impact of rate fluctuations on the economy. He specifically focused on how rates impact consumers' ability to borrow and save. He also has authored a wee
Conditions… Variable APR of Prime minus 1.01% in all states. Min loan amount $10,000. Max loan amount $200,000. 30-year term. Annual fee waived for the first year. See conditions for guarantee at thirdfederal.com.
Third Federal rate are typically 20% lower than other leaders
Guaranteed Lowest Rate
No closing costs, prepayment penalties, or minimum draw requirements
Rates/terms are subject to change. All offers of credit are subject to credit approval. Applicants may be offered credit at higher rates and other terms. Property insurance (including flood insurance, if applicable) is required. HELOCs not offered in Texas. Membership at FourLeaf is required by opening a minimum $5 share account.
Rates shown are based on primary residence, minimum initial draw of $25,000 at account opening, monthly payments via automatic transfers from a FourLeaf checking/savings account, and borrower(s) inputs for credit score and Combined Loan-to-Value.
If borrower(s) qualifies for an intro rate, the intro APR is fixed for 12 months. After, standard APR is variable based on the U.S. Prime Rate, plus a margin, and is subject to increase. To obtain an intro rate, borrower(s) must meet credit/loan program requirements, including (but not limited to): 1) maximum CLTV of 75%, 2) minimum credit score of 720 3) initial draw of $25,000 and maintain this balance for 12 months, 4) monthly payments via automatic transfers from a FourLeaf checking/savings account, and 5) have not had an intro rate within the past 5 years. Loan amounts over $500,000 are not available for the intro rate.
The standard APR is variable based on the U.S. Prime Rate as published in the Wall Street Journal, plus a margin (if applicable), and is subject to increase after consummation. The current standard APR ranges from 7.50% - 18.00% as of 4/16/2025. Not all applicants will qualify for the lowest rate. The minimum floor APR is 3.25% and maximum is 18%. Prime Rate as of 4/16/2025 = 7.50%. Closing costs for the first $500,000 will be paid by FourLeaf but must be repaid by the borrower(s) if the HELOC is closed within first 36 months of account opening. Fees generally range between $500 - $15,000. Borrower(s) will be responsible for mortgage-related taxes and title insurance costs on the line amounts over $500,000. Fees generally range between $500 -$60,000.
Tap into your home's equity & access the funds you need with a HELOC
Apply online or speak with a specialist
No application, origination & appraisal fees on lines up to $500K[3]
Pointʼs Home Equity Investment (HEI) is an entirely new way to unlock your homeʼs wealth. Point partners with and invests alongside the homeowner in the property. Subject to underwriting approval, Point will pay you an upfront, lump sum amount in exchange for a portion of your home’s future appreciation. Future appreciation is based on using the risk adjusted Appreciation Starting Value and calculating any gain or loss based on the final appraised value of your home at the time of exit. Point charges up to a 3.9% processing fee (subject to a $2,000 minimum) and other third party paid closing costs such as appraisal, escrow, and government fees. The term is 30 years. Point will place a lien on your home to secure performance of the underlying agreement. There are no monthly payments or interest accrual. Homeowner’s repayment amount is based on the future value of the subject property at the time of exit, as outlined in the underlying agreement.
No income requirements or need for perfect credit
Your home wealth, to use your way
Find out if you qualify in as little as 60 seconds
Home Equity Investments are not considered a loan in all states
Home Equity loans are available through our affiliate Achieve Loans (NMLS ID #1810501). Equal Housing Opportunity. Offers may vary and loan requests are subject to eligibility requirements, application review, loan amount, loan term, and lender approval. Product terms are subject to change at any time. Offers are a line of credit. Loans are not available to residents of all states and available loan terms/fees may vary by state where offered. Line amounts are between $15,000 and $300,000 and are assigned based on product type, debt-to-income ratio, and combined loan-to-value ratio. 10, 15, 20, and 30-year terms available. Minimum 600 credit score applies for debt consolidation requests (20 and 30 year terms require a minimum credit score of 640), minimum 700 applies for cash out requests. Other terms, conditions and restrictions apply. Fixed rate APRs range from 6.74% - 14.75% and are assigned based on underwriting requirements; offer APRs may include a discount for automatic payment enrollment (autopay enrollment is not a condition of loan approval). All terms have a 5-year draw period with the remaining term being a no draw period. Payments are fully amortized during each period and determined on the outstanding principal balance each month and can fluctuate during the draw period. Closing fees range from $750 to $6,685, depending on line amount and state law requirements and typically include origination (3.5% of line amount) and underwriting ($725) fees if allowed by law. Property must be owner-occupied. Combined loan-to-value ratio may not exceed 80% (20 and 30 year debt consolidation requests may not exceed 75%), including the new loan request. Property insurance is required and flood insurance may be required if the subject property is located in a flood zone. You must pledge your home as collateral. Equal Housing Opportunity. Contact Achieve Loans for further details.
Competitive rates, Pre-qualify in minutes
Mortgage Advisors standing by to help find the best solution
• Home Equity Loans & Refinance – Cash out
• Customized rate quote with no impact to credit
• Low Rates, Quick Approvals, Wide Range of Products
• Over 100 Billion Funded. 22 Years in Business
Home Equity Loans & Refinance – Cash out
Customized rate quote with no impact to credit
Low Rates, Quick Approvals, Wide Range of Products
Add your Comment
or use your BestCashCow account