New York

Image Courtesy: pixabay.com

Garden City, New York Savings Rates

You are viewing savings rates from banks in Garden City, New York

 

If you have your savings dollars in a big bank or a bank with low savings rates, then you are losing money. We've found FDIC insured banks that will pay you more. Take a few minutes to explore the options below and see how you can boost your savings by more than 6X the national average rate. There is competition for your money. Take advantage of it!

Garden City, NY - June 15, 2025

Savings Account National Average Rate: 0.45% ?

Banks APY MIN

Promotional rate for 3 months up to $11,000. Requires $25,000 in new deposits within 10 days of registration. After 3 month promotional period, rate reverts to between 0.03% and 0.12%.
Rate History: 5.00% → 4.75% → 5.00% → 4.50% → 4.35%

| Feb 25, 2022

I joined Citi with a Costco-VISA card. An Accelerate followed, and then a checking account. Costco-VISA is necessary for using a credit card at Costco, otherwise cash is necessary. Accelerate Savings w... Read More

Requires checking account.
Rate History: 5.14% → 5.24% → 4.73% → 4.48% → 4.23%

| Mar 25, 2020

I was told on the phone by a bank rep that my present money market acct interest rate would continue at 2.25% until June 30, 2020 and would be FDIC covered up to $250,000. Please verify if this is true???... Read More

Rate History: 4.25% → 4.00%

Rate History: 5.00% → 4.40% → 4.25% → 4.15% → 4.00%

| Oct 2, 2015

I have a CD maturing on 11/15 please email your CD Rates and contact info. Read More

3.80%

$50,000

Learn More

Rate History: 4.50% → 4.15% → 3.90% → 3.70%

| Mar 20, 2016

Good solid bank. Read More

Rate History: 4.00% → 3.70%

| May 19, 2018

Experience Read More

Rate History: 4.10% → 4.00% → 3.90% → 3.80% → 3.60%

| Jan 2, 2024

Like others, I've been with Capital One and its predecessor ING Direct since 2007. I've also been getting cheap bank rates on my savings account and didn't realize that there was something better, although... Read More

Rate History: 4.00% → 3.85% → 3.75% → 3.70% → 3.60%

| Apr 14, 2020

I call HSBC they told me they don't have 1.85 1 year CD. current CD is 0.8 / year Read More

Rate History: 1.00% → 3.50%

Rate History: 4.00% → 3.35%

| Feb 5, 2020

The employees of this bank are helpful but the bank's systems and procedures for obtaining your account information STINK. If you want a bank that provides you quarterly (or even annual) statements by mai... Read More

| Dec 3, 2019

Have done business with "Hope's" San Diego branch for a few years. Always courteous and helpful. Looking forward to doing business with them in the future. Read More

Rate History: 1.00% → 3.00%

| Mar 20, 2016

Good solid bank. Read More

Rate History: 3.50% → 3.00% → 2.75% → 2.50%

| Jan 18, 2024

Hi, We've noticed your website is at risk due to spammy comments and contact form submissions, making it susceptible to issues like spammy backlinks and data breaches. Don't worry—there's a simple sol... Read More

| Jan 2, 2024

Like others, I've been with Capital One and its predecessor ING Direct since 2007. I've also been getting cheap bank rates on my savings account and didn't realize that there was something better, although... Read More

Rate History: 2.27% → 5.25% → 2.27% → 2.17% → 2.07%

| Jul 1, 2022

Very easy opening process and wonderful staff. Read More

Rate History: 1.75% → 0.70% → 1.75% → 1.65%

| Dec 2, 2022

No such limits as referred to by Jonathan. Perfectly Happy with service and keep adjusting the rate! Read More

Rate History: 1.26% → 1.76% → 1.51% → 1.41% → 1.36%

Rate History: 1.01% → 1.02% → 1.01%

| Feb 6, 2023

after over 100k in transactions through this bank in the course of a year not only did i suffer from fraud but this bank closed my accounts and i have been lliable for all the losses and to top it off with... Read More

| Feb 13, 2018

Is it legal to bring someone into the branch and shake them down and threaten them when they want to redeem their CD upon maturity (as opposed to allowing it to automatically renew)? If not, these guys an... Read More

| Jun 15, 2017

Just a great group of people to interact with at the Mineola branch. Been working with them for years. Everybody at all of the branches has always been a pleasure. Read More

Rate History: 0.35% → 0.60%

| Feb 13, 2018

Is it legal to bring someone into the branch and shake them down and threaten them when they want to redeem their CD upon maturity (as opposed to allowing it to automatically renew)? If not, these guys an... Read More

| Aug 19, 2021

Best Service! Read More

Rate History: 1.36% → 1.11% → 0.85% → 0.60% → 0.50%

Rate History: 0.60% → 0.50%

| Oct 2, 2015

I have a CD maturing on 11/15 please email your CD Rates and contact info. Read More

0.50%

$25,000

Learn More

0.50%

$10,000

Learn More

0.50%

$2,500

Learn More

Rate History: 0.75% → 0.65% → 1.75% → 0.50% → 0.40%

| Dec 2, 2022

No such limits as referred to by Jonathan. Perfectly Happy with service and keep adjusting the rate! Read More

Rate History: 4.65% → 0.35%

| Apr 25, 2022

We would not be having all this trouble with people sealing money out of other people's bank accounts if we were to just stop using fancy banking like onlinebanki Read More

0.35%

$25,000

Learn More

| Aug 19, 2021

Best Service! Read More

0.30%

$2,500

Learn More

| Mar 10, 2021

I think that it is absolutely despicable that I have been a customer of the Bank for more than 8 years and I bring in rolled coins with my account number on each wrapper and I am charged 5% fee. Cost me $3... Read More

0.25%

$2,500

Learn More

Rate History: 0.35% → 0.25%

0.25%

$2,500

Learn More

0.25%

$2,500

Learn More

| Mar 28, 2023

On line banking gives a confirmation number when paying bills. But it doesn’t confirm that the bill will be paid only that they have the information. Ridiculous. Read More

0.20%

$0

Learn More

0.20%

$2,500

Learn More

Rate History: 0.20% → 0.15% → 0.20%

0.20%

$2,500

Learn More

| Mar 10, 2021

I think that it is absolutely despicable that I have been a customer of the Bank for more than 8 years and I bring in rolled coins with my account number on each wrapper and I am charged 5% fee. Cost me $3... Read More

0.20%

$10,000

Learn More

0.20%

$2,500

Learn More

0.15%

$2,500

Learn More

0.15%

$2,500

Learn More

0.15%

$25,000

Learn More

0.10%

$2,500

Learn More

0.10%

$2,500

Learn More

Rate History: 0.25% → 0.10%

0.10%

$2,500

Learn More

0.10%

$10,000

Learn More

0.10%

$2,500

Learn More

Rate History: 4.00% → 3.55% → 3.50% → 0.07% → 0.06%

| Apr 4, 2016

I been with trustco for years and it is well run. They really are a home town bank. As a small business person i appreciate the business card stand they have in the branches for there customers. I was w... Read More

You must have a Premier Checking account to obtain this rate.

| May 11, 2023

They made mistakes twice and would not correct them Read More

Rate History: 0.60% → 0.40% → 0.30% → 0.15% → 0.05%

| Dec 2, 2022

No such limits as referred to by Jonathan. Perfectly Happy with service and keep adjusting the rate! Read More

0.05%

$2,500

Learn More

0.05%

$1

Learn More

0.05%

$0

Learn More

0.05%

$2,500

Learn More

| Jun 15, 2017

Just a great group of people to interact with at the Mineola branch. Been working with them for years. Everybody at all of the branches has always been a pleasure. Read More

0.05%

$2,500

Learn More

| Mar 15, 2023

Oh Natty natty natty, haha the fact you need to take out (probably a second) loan for $160,000 on a $625,000 sends up all kinds of red flags. The bank was right to run away from YOU dear hahaha. Read More

0.05%

$1

Learn More

0.05%

$2,500

Learn More

0.05%

$2,500

Learn More

0.05%

$2,500

Learn More

Rate History: 4.00% → 3.55% → 3.50% → 0.08% → 0.05%

| Apr 4, 2016

I been with trustco for years and it is well run. They really are a home town bank. As a small business person i appreciate the business card stand they have in the branches for there customers. I was w... Read More

| Jul 24, 2023

BOFA is a den of people thieves camouflaged as bank operatives. There’s a soon to be uncovered carrel of money laundry there. They took all my money and don’t want to release it to me for no particular... Read More

| May 11, 2023

They made mistakes twice and would not correct them Read More

Rate History: 1.00% → 0.05% → 0.02%

| May 18, 2019

Had checking and savings for years when living in Philly. Went into PNC 2.35 APY high yield savings. They have thus far maintained rate. Easy web site and great customer phone service. Still maintain check... Read More

0.02%

$2,500

Learn More

| Jan 2, 2023

Terrible customer service by investment side. Fees too high , too full of themselves Read More

Rate History: 0.03% → 0.01%

| May 18, 2019

Had checking and savings for years when living in Philly. Went into PNC 2.35 APY high yield savings. They have thus far maintained rate. Easy web site and great customer phone service. Still maintain check... Read More

| Mar 28, 2023

On line banking gives a confirmation number when paying bills. But it doesn’t confirm that the bill will be paid only that they have the information. Ridiculous. Read More

| Aug 5, 2020

I used to go to M&T when it was still Provident Bank. M&T has been very responsive to my needs and I have been pleased with the banking experience. Read More

0.01%

$0

Learn More

0.01%

$2,500

Learn More

0.01%

$1

Learn More
All rates listed are Annual Percentage Yield (APY). The APY rate in a savings account or money market account is a variable rate that is subject to change at any point. The Min listed is the minimum deposit account balance required to obtain the rate listed.


Branches Info around Garden City, NY - June 15, 2025


Branch Street City State
Citibank, National Association
Soho Financial Center Branch
476 Broadway New York NY
Customers Bank
Osborn Branch
101 Theall Road Rye NY
Spring Bank
Harlem Branch - Frederick Douglas Blvd
301 W. 111th Street New York NY
Popular Bank
Court Street Branch
66 Court Street Brooklyn NY
Popular Bank
Court Street Branch
66 Court Street Brooklyn NY
CTBC Bank Corp. (USA)
Brooklyn Branch
54-18 8th Avenue Brooklyn NY
Apple Bank
Downing Street Branch
10 Downing Street New York NY
BankUnited, National Association
Borough Park Brooklyn Branch
1333 60th Street Brooklyn NY
Spring Bank
Harlem Branch - Frederick Douglas Blvd
301 W. 111th Street New York NY
Citizens
Yonkers Branch
2371 Central Park Avenue Yonkers NY
TD Bank, National Association
Greenwich & 8th Avenue Branch
122 Greenwich Avenue New York NY
Capital One, National Association
23rd & 9th Branch
401 West 23rd Street New York NY
HSBC Bank USA, National Association
8th Avenue And 14th Street Branch
80 Eighth Avenue New York City NY
Kearny Bank
Brooklyn Branch
689 Fifth Ave Brooklyn NY
The First National Bank of Long Island
37th Street Branch
232 Madison Avenue New York NY
Hanover Community Bank
Hanover Community Bank Branch
2131 Jericho Turnpike Garden City Park NY
Apple Bank
Downing Street Branch
10 Downing Street New York NY
Bank of Hope
Manhattan Branch
16 West 32nd Street New York NY
Citizens
Yonkers Branch
2371 Central Park Avenue Yonkers NY
New Millennium Bank
Bayside Branch
209-35 Northern Boulevard Bayside NY
Apple Bank
Downing Street Branch
10 Downing Street New York NY
Citizens
Yonkers Branch
2371 Central Park Avenue Yonkers NY
ConnectOne Bank
Madison Avenue Branch Office
551 Madison Avenue New York NY
Capital One, National Association
23rd & 9th Branch
401 West 23rd Street New York NY
The First National Bank of Long Island
37th Street Branch
232 Madison Avenue New York NY
New Millennium Bank
Bayside Branch
209-35 Northern Boulevard Bayside NY
TD Bank, National Association
Greenwich & 8th Avenue Branch
122 Greenwich Avenue New York NY
Amalgamated Bank
Amalgamated Bank Branch
275 Seventh Avenue New York NY
M.Y. Safra Bank
M.Y. Safra Bank, Fsb Branch
499 Park Avenue New York NY
Popular Bank
Court Street Branch
66 Court Street Brooklyn NY
New Millennium Bank
Bayside Branch
209-35 Northern Boulevard Bayside NY
Amalgamated Bank
Amalgamated Bank Branch
275 Seventh Avenue New York NY
Valley National Bank
Broadway Branch
450 Broadway New York NY
The First National Bank of Long Island
37th Street Branch
232 Madison Avenue New York NY
Amalgamated Bank
Amalgamated Bank Branch
275 Seventh Avenue New York NY
Wells Fargo Bank, National Association
Broadway & Grand Branch
463 Broadway New York NY
Apple Bank
Downing Street Branch
10 Downing Street New York NY
Amalgamated Bank
Amalgamated Bank Branch
275 Seventh Avenue New York NY
Habib American Bank
Habib American Bank Branch
99 Madison Avenue New York NY
Flushing Bank
Montague Street Branch
186 Montague Street Brooklyn NY
Habib American Bank
Habib American Bank Branch
99 Madison Avenue New York NY
Amerasia Bank
86-26 Broadway Branch
86-26 Broadway Elmhurst NY
City National Bank
6th Avenue Branch
1140 6th Avenue New York NY
Popular Bank
Court Street Branch
66 Court Street Brooklyn NY
The Berkshire Bank
Brooklyn Branch
5010 13th Avenue New York City NY
Maspeth Federal Savings and Loan Association
101-09 Metropolitan Ave Branch
101-09 Metropolitan Ave New York City NY
Esquire Bank, National Association
Esquire Bank, National Association Branch
320 Old Country Rd. Garden City NY
Global Bank
Global Bank Branch
8 Catherine Street New York NY
State Bank of India
State Bank Of India Branch
460 Park Avenue New York NY
Valley National Bank
Broadway Branch
450 Broadway New York NY
Cross County Savings Bank
Kings Branch
731 Metropolitan Ave. Brooklyn NY
Popular Bank
Court Street Branch
66 Court Street Brooklyn NY
Popular Bank
Court Street Branch
66 Court Street Brooklyn NY
Ridgewood Savings Bank
Cobble Hill Branch
244 Court Street Brooklyn NY
Carver Federal Savings Bank
Atlantic Terminal Branch
4 Hanson Place Brooklyn NY
Amerasia Bank
86-26 Broadway Branch
86-26 Broadway Elmhurst NY
Popular Bank
Court Street Branch
66 Court Street Brooklyn NY
Carver Federal Savings Bank
Atlantic Terminal Branch
4 Hanson Place Brooklyn NY
Shinhan Bank America
Manhattan Branch
313 Fifth Avenue New York NY
Cathay Bank
Soho Branch
129 Lafayette Street New York NY
NorthEast Community Bank
West 23rd Branch
242 West 23rd Street New York City NY
Apple Bank
Downing Street Branch
10 Downing Street New York NY
Ridgewood Savings Bank
Cobble Hill Branch
244 Court Street Brooklyn NY
Cross County Savings Bank
Kings Branch
731 Metropolitan Ave. Brooklyn NY
Carver Federal Savings Bank
Atlantic Terminal Branch
4 Hanson Place Brooklyn NY
Alma Bank
13th Avenue Branch
4401 13th Avenue Brooklyn NY
KeyBank National Association
11 East 22nd Street Branch
11 East 22nd Street New York City NY
Cathay Bank
Soho Branch
129 Lafayette Street New York NY
PCSB Bank
Mount Vernon Br Branch
40 East First Street Mount Vernon NY
Ponce Bank
Bensonhurst Branch
2047 86th Street Brooklyn NY
Metropolitan Commercial Bank
Boro Park Branch
5101 13th Ave Brooklyn NY
Shinhan Bank America
Manhattan Branch
313 Fifth Avenue New York NY
Alma Bank
13th Avenue Branch
4401 13th Avenue Brooklyn NY
United Orient Bank
United Orient Bank Branch
185 Canal Street New York City NY
Global Bank
Global Bank Branch
8 Catherine Street New York NY
Citibank, National Association
Soho Financial Center Branch
476 Broadway New York NY
Amalgamated Bank
Amalgamated Bank Branch
275 Seventh Avenue New York NY
BankUnited, National Association
Borough Park Brooklyn Branch
1333 60th Street Brooklyn NY
New Millennium Bank
Bayside Branch
209-35 Northern Boulevard Bayside NY
The Berkshire Bank
Brooklyn Branch
5010 13th Avenue New York City NY
Alma Bank
13th Avenue Branch
4401 13th Avenue Brooklyn NY
Industrial and Commercial Bank of China USA, National Association
Industrial And Commercial Bank Of China Usa, National Association Branch
1633 Broadway New York NY
Northfield Bank
Boro Park Branch
4602 13th Ave Brooklyn NY
PCSB Bank
Mount Vernon Br Branch
40 East First Street Mount Vernon NY
The Berkshire Bank
Brooklyn Branch
5010 13th Avenue New York City NY
Ponce Bank
Bensonhurst Branch
2047 86th Street Brooklyn NY
Sunnyside Federal Savings and Loan Association of Irvington
Sunnyside Federal Savings And Loan A Branch
56 Main St Irvington NY
Hana Bank USA, National Association
Fifth Avenue Branch
309 5th Avenue New York NY
Interaudi Bank
Interaudi Bank Branch
19 East 54th Street New York NY
Industrial and Commercial Bank of China USA, National Association
Industrial And Commercial Bank Of China Usa, National Association Branch
1633 Broadway New York NY
TrustCo Bank
Bronxville Branch
5-7 Park Place Bronxville NY
Santander Bank, N.A.
86th Street Branch
1769 86th Street Brooklyn NY
Valley National Bank
Broadway Branch
450 Broadway New York NY
Cathay Bank
Soho Branch
129 Lafayette Street New York NY
Abacus Federal Savings Bank
Abacus Federal Savings Bank Branch
6 Bowery New York NY
Preferred Bank
Flushing Branch
41-60 Main Street Flushing NY
Kearny Bank
Brooklyn Branch
689 Fifth Ave Brooklyn NY
Northfield Bank
Boro Park Branch
4602 13th Ave Brooklyn NY
Dime Community Bank
52nd Street Manhattan Branch
12 East 52nd Street New York NY
Flushing Bank
Montague Street Branch
186 Montague Street Brooklyn NY
Metropolitan Commercial Bank
Boro Park Branch
5101 13th Ave Brooklyn NY
East West Bank
Canal Branch
208 Canal Street New York NY
Eastbank, National Association
Eastbank, National Association Branch
183 Centre Street New York NY
Hana Bank USA, National Association
Fifth Avenue Branch
309 5th Avenue New York NY
Fieldpoint Private Bank & Trust
Fieldpoint Private Bank & Trust Bran Branch
400 Park Avenue Suite 1800 New York NY
Industrial and Commercial Bank of China USA, National Association
Industrial And Commercial Bank Of China Usa, National Association Branch
1633 Broadway New York NY
TrustCo Bank
Bronxville Branch
5-7 Park Place Bronxville NY
Bank of America, National Association
7th And Christopher Branch
224 W 4th St New York NY
Santander Bank, N.A.
86th Street Branch
1769 86th Street Brooklyn NY
PNC Bank, National Association
11 Penn Plaza Branch
Seventh Avenue And West 31st Street New York NY
Webster Bank, National Association
Yonkers Branch
760 Mclean Ave Yonkers NY
JPMorgan Chase Bank, National Association
Sheridan Square Branch
204 West Fourth Street New York City NY
Wells Fargo Bank, National Association
Broadway & Grand Branch
463 Broadway New York NY
HSBC Bank USA, National Association
8th Avenue And 14th Street Branch
80 Eighth Avenue New York City NY
PNC Bank, National Association
11 Penn Plaza Branch
Seventh Avenue And West 31st Street New York NY
KeyBank National Association
11 East 22nd Street Branch
11 East 22nd Street New York City NY
Manufacturers and Traders Trust Company
World Wide Plaza Branch
830 Eighth Avenue New York NY
City National Bank
6th Avenue Branch
1140 6th Avenue New York NY
Northfield Bank
Boro Park Branch
4602 13th Ave Brooklyn NY
Webster Bank, National Association
Yonkers Branch
760 Mclean Ave Yonkers NY
Alpine Capital Bank
Alpine Capital Bank Branch
680 Fifth Avenue, 7th Floor New York NY


BestCashCow strives to maintain the most accurate rates. If you believe a rate is not accurate, please let us know.

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS ABOUT LOCAL SAVINGS RATES


Why do savings rates vary so much?

Even though rates are at levels that are historically very low, there is competition for your money. Like any active marketplace, there are buyers and sellers of goods and services at different prices. Banks have different cost structures and they also have different needs for capital. This leads to different rates.

BestCashCow’s surveys show that online banks offer higher savings and CD rates because they have lower expenses from not having to maintain brick-and-mortar locations. Therefore, we strongly recommend that all depositors consider the rates at online banks as savings and money market accounts online can easy be set up to enable quick transfers to your favorite local bank.

What is the difference between a savings account and a money market account?

The differences between a savings account and a money market account are largely arcane. Some money market accounts offer more ways access deposits by issuing checks and debit cards, but prudent consumers will compare the two interchangeably, focusing primarily on rates and service among FDIC-insured banks (or NCUA-insured, for credit unions). Most savvy consumers who plan their expenses and financial needs ahead find the additional functionality offered by money markets to be of little value and will choose whichever account (savings or money market) has the higher rate.

What does annual percentage yield (APY) mean?

Savings rates are displayed in terms of APY to indicate the effective annual-interest return, including the compounding of interest, of the course of a single year. $100,000 deposited in a savings or CD account with a 1.20% APY will earn $1,200 in the course of the year, but monthly interest in the first few months may be less than $100 a month (this also depends on the number of days in the month). Hence, the APY rate is ordinarily a couple of basis points above the real interest rates. Unlike with a Certificate of Deposit, your actual APY in a savings may vary if the rate changes.

How do I choose the right savings account and should I consider CDs?

Begin your search with the table here on BestCashCow.com that you have found. In addition to checking online savings rates, you should also check local bank rates and local credit union rates. If you are unlikely to require access to your cash for some time, you may also consider certificates of deposit (CDs). While CDs have penalties for early withdrawal that may even eat into your principal, the rates on 2, 3, 4 and 5 year CDs are ordinarily significantly higher than savings rates. Several other sections and articles on BestCashCow can also help you to identify your proper cash allocation between savings and CDs. Access these below. You should also familiarize yourself with our Savings & CD Calculator in order to understand the importance of compounding interest at higher rates on your savings over time.

8 POINT CHECKLIST FOR A GREAT BANKING RELATIONSHIP WITH YOUR LOCAL BANK

  • Find a bank with a location convenient to you. Location counts.
  • Choose a bank with good rates. Rates are important to get continued growth of your capital.
  • Choose a bank with an extensive network of fee-free ATM machines or which reimburses out-of-network ATM fees, if you still need to regularly access cash.
  • Avoid fees. Choose a bank which doesn’t have service fees provided you maintain a certain balance, which doesn’t charge for ACH inbound and outbound transfers, and which has low fees for things like international wire transfers and bounced checks.
  • Choose a healthy bank. If you click on a bank above, you’ll be taken to the bank’s financial detail. A healthy bank has happy employees and provides loyal service to its customers. No matter how healthy your bank is, stay within FDIC insurance limits.
  • Find something of value to offset what may be slightly lower rates than online accounts offer. Develop personal relationship with your bankers. Personal relationships can help you to get appropriate financial advice, and to navigate financial challenges and needs in the future. (Be careful with the financial advice you receive. Inappropriate financial advice is worth a lot less than no financial advice.) They can also put you in touch with others in your community who could be valuable personally and professionally to know. If you don't use your local savings account as an opportunity to build these relationships, you may find that you are better of banking online.
  • Choose a bank that is going to let you access your cash when you need. The great benefit of savings accounts over any other financial product (including CDs) is that you have absolute liquidity. If your bank in creating impediments to accessing your cash (paperwork, fees, etc.), then you need another bank.
  • Be aware that you can have more than one account. Having a great local savings account at a large or small bank near you can be great, but it doesn't need to stop you from opening one or more online savings accounts, or even developing a relationship with another local bank or credit union.

SAVINGS & CD CALCULATOR

Find out how much extra money you can earn by moving your bank money into an account that pays more.